Insights & Rankings Compare

Compare ZIP codes side by side

Line up 2–5 ZIP codes and read the ZipVitals Score, both ranks, and every scoring domain against the same national scale. Descriptive of documented conditions — never a verdict on the people who live there.

Comparing06390Fishers Island, NY12419Cottekill, NY2–5 ZIPs · 2 selected

ZipVitals Score and its national and state ranks, compared across 2 ZIP codes. Higher is healthier. The nine scoring domains follow, one table each.
Metric	Fishers Island06390 · NY	Cottekill12419 · NY
ZipVitals ScoreComposite of 9 scoring domains	66.57 Leads	63.64
National rankAmong ZIPs with a computed score	#1,417of 32,066 US ZIPs Leads	#2,640of 32,066 US ZIPs
State rankAmong ZIPs with a computed score	#205of 1,730 NY ZIPs	#352of 1,730 NY ZIPs
Metro rankAmong ZIPs with a computed score	#357of 853 ZIPs in its metro area	#7of 52 ZIPs in its metro area

ZipVitals Score and its national and state ranks, compared across 2 ZIP codes. Higher is healthier. The nine scoring domains follow, one table each.
Metric	Fishers Island06390 · NY	Cottekill12419 · NY
ZipVitals Score	66.57 Leads	63.64
National rank	#1,417of 32,066 US ZIPs Leads	#2,640of 32,066 US ZIPs
State rank	#205of 1,730 NY ZIPs	#352of 1,730 NY ZIPs
Metro rank	#357of 853 ZIPs in its metro area	#7of 52 ZIPs in its metro area

ZipVitals Score — Composite of 9 scoring domainsNational rank, State rank and Metro rank — Among ZIPs with a computed score

Metro areas — 06390: New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ · 12419: Kingston, NY.

Where these ZIPs differ, domain by domain

Nine domains make up the ZipVitals Score. Each one is placed on the same national scale, and the domains where these ZIPs are furthest apart come first. Higher is healthier in every one.

Compared with the ZIP codes measured across all nine scoring domains — not with all US ZIP codes. How the score works, and who it compares you with ›

Every ranking, bar and gap below is measured against the same national group. Where a ZIP’s line also mentions its state or its metro area, that figure is measured against a different group — its own — so it is context for that one ZIP and never a comparison between them.

Furthest apart first

all 2 ZIPs can be placed on these 8 domains

Environmental Hazard14% of the score 06390 leads · 28-point gap
06390Fishers Island		healthier than 94% · 98% in New York, 99% in its metro area	1 of 2
12419Cottekill		healthier than 66% · 63% in New York, 68% in its metro area	2 of 2

Social Need / SDOH16% of the score 12419 leads · 14-point gap
12419Cottekill		healthier than 65% · 60% in New York, 82% in its metro area	1 of 2
06390Fishers Island		healthier than 51% · 45% in New York, 27% in its metro area	2 of 2

Chronic Disease Burden21% of the score 06390 leads · 9-point gap
06390Fishers Island		healthier than 75% · 57% in New York, 18% in its metro area	1 of 2
12419Cottekill		healthier than 66% · 43% in New York, 64% in its metro area	2 of 2

Mental Health8% of the score 06390 leads · 7-point gap
06390Fishers Island		healthier than 97% · 84% in New York, 57% in its metro area	1 of 2
12419Cottekill		healthier than 90% · 64% in New York, 80% in its metro area	2 of 2

Preventive Care13% of the score 06390 leads · 2-point gap
06390Fishers Island		healthier than 98% · 91% in New York, 94% in its metro area	1 of 2
12419Cottekill		healthier than 96% · 84% in New York, 80% in its metro area	2 of 2

Risk Behavior11% of the score 12419 leads · 2-point gap
12419Cottekill		healthier than 88% · 90% in New York, 82% in its metro area	1 of 2
06390Fishers Island		healthier than 86% · 87% in New York, 69% in its metro area	2 of 2

Disability7% of the score 06390 leads · 2-point gap
06390Fishers Island		healthier than 92% · 81% in New York, 56% in its metro area	1 of 2
12419Cottekill		healthier than 90% · 76% in New York, 96% in its metro area	2 of 2

Healthcare Access5% of the score 06390 leads · 1-point gap
06390Fishers Island		healthier than 44% · 35% in New York, 9% in its metro area	1 of 2
12419Cottekill		healthier than 43% · 35% in New York, 44% in its metro area	2 of 2

Not every ZIP can be placed here

no leader and no gap — ordered by weight instead

Climate / Disaster Risk5% of the scoreno leader — 06390 cannot be placed here
12419Cottekill		healthier than 81% · 52% in New York, 68% in its metro area	1 of 1
06390Fishers Island	not placed — too little of this domain is measured here to compare reliably, though it still counts toward this ZIP’s score

“Of the score” is the domain’s weight in the ZipVitals Score — a property of the score itself, the same on every ZIP. A gap is the distance between the highest and lowest of these ZIPs on that domain’s national scale. Percentages are rounded; higher is healthier in every domain.

Data release 2026 · higher is healthier on every row. How the ZipVitals Score is calculated →

The State rank and Metro rank rows show no “Leads” marker: each ZIP is ranked against the ZIPs in its own state and the ZIPs in its own metro area, so those ranks are not ordered against one another.

Share this comparison

This comparison has its own permalink and an auto-generated preview card — the image that unfurls when you paste the link into a message, post, or story.

ZipVitalsZipVitals Score · compare

Fishers Island vs. Cottekill

Fishers Island 06390 · NYLEADS66.57

Cottekill 12419 · NY63.64

Data release 2026 · public federal and academic sources · higher is healthier

Preview of the auto-generated share card · ZipVitals Score, 0–100